Coaching Gen Z: The Career Crisis That Isn’t

By Mitchell Schuckman, PCC | Executive Coach + Founder, The Schuckman Group LLC


A former colleague called recently with a question that seemed to make him uncomfortable. His daughter, in her mid-20s, was having what he described as a career crisis. Did I know someone who might coach her?

I couldn’t help smiling at the idea of a career crisis at 25. How much of a career could she possibly have had to be in crisis about? I told him I’d be happy to work with her myself, which seemed to surprise him. Perhaps he assumed that someone who coaches senior executives wouldn’t be interested in someone just starting out.

What he didn’t know was that this was the fifth time in six months a friend or former colleague had asked me about coaching a young adult child. Each time, I said yes. And these conversations, with people ranging from college students to young professionals, have been among my most interesting.

I’ve raised four children through their 20s, so I know how much parents want their children to be happy and find their way. I also know how hard it can be to watch them struggle. As a coach, though, I can see possibilities they haven’t considered and strengths they haven’t recognized, without carrying the same emotional investment in the outcome.

Who Decided There Was a Timetable?

One pattern I’ve noticed is how quickly young adults conclude that they’re falling behind. A college student worries about choosing the wrong major or internship. A recent graduate compares job offers with friends. A young professional sees someone else promoted and wonders whether a disappointing first job has derailed an entire career.

Social media makes the comparisons almost unavoidable. Everyone else’s achievements arrive as announcements, while their own uncertainty feels private and personal. A setback can become evidence that they’ve made a terrible mistake, even when they’re only a few years into exploring what they might enjoy doing.

When I coach someone through that uncertainty, I’m interested in what they’re learning about themselves, including from the things that haven’t gone as planned. That often proves more useful than trying to decide whether they’re ahead of or behind someone else.

The Detours May Be the Education

Looking back on 40 years of work, I can identify assignments I didn’t enjoy, opportunities I missed, and people I found difficult. Some of those experiences eventually became more valuable than the ones I had carefully planned.

It’s difficult to appreciate that when you’re 21 and convinced that the next internship determines your future, or 26 and wondering whether you’ve chosen the wrong profession. Yet an experience that feels like a failure can reveal what energizes you, what frustrates you, and what you’re capable of handling.

In coaching, we examine those experiences before assigning them a verdict. What happened? What did you do? What would you repeat or change? Often, what initially sounded like a career crisis turns into a much more interesting conversation about choices and possibilities.

They Have Stories They Can’t Yet Tell

One college student I coach has accumulated an impressive collection of experiences through part-time jobs, travel, and personal projects. Yet when we began preparing for interviews, the student struggled to explain why any of those experiences mattered.

We worked through the stories, looking at decisions made, challenges encountered, and lessons learned. Gradually, the student began to recognize qualities that had been there all along, including initiative, judgment, curiosity, and persistence. Through practice, he also became a proficient storyteller, tying his experiences to the value he would bring to an opportunity.

I’ve spent years helping rising professionals and senior executives tell their stories more effectively. It was striking to see how useful the same work could be at the beginning of a career, when a young person is still developing a sense of what they bring to the table.

Even Gen Z Is Worried About Change

Another college student, majoring in finance, was concerned that AI and changes in business would make finance a dead-end, or at least an unispiring career. I found that surprising. I had assumed that a generation growing up with constant technological change would be more comfortable with an uncertain future.

We talked about what studying finance actually provides. Understanding how money moves through a business, how decisions affect profitability, and how to evaluate an investment can be useful in almost any profession. Those skills matter if you work in the financial services industry, or start your own business.

AI may change many finance jobs, and no one can promise exactly what those jobs will look like. But a college major doesn’t have to dictate a single occupation for the next 40 years. Sometimes the learning experience provides value in its own right.

Why the Conversation Has to Be Theirs

That independence matters. Parents have a lifetime of love, hopes, and worries invested in their children. I’ve experienced that myself with four kids. A coach can ask difficult questions, challenge assumptions, and listen without having a family history attached to every answer.

Much of what I’ve learned from coaching executives applies here: helping people recognize their strengths, examine their choices, and build the confidence to act. The difference is that a young adult has decades ahead to benefit from discovering those things early.

I don’t think every anxious college student or uncertain young professional is facing a crisis. Often they’re just beginning to understand themselves. The dots don’t need to connect today. There are plenty more to collect.

Mitchell Schuckman is the Founder and CEO of The Schuckman Group LLC. He is a Professional Certified Coach credentialed by the International Coaching Federation and the author of I'll Tell You a Great Story. theschuckmangroup.com

Note on privacy: Names and identifying details have been changed. The experiences described are drawn from multiple client engagements and do not represent any single individual.

Next
Next

You Met 67 People at a Conference. Now What?